Moderators: Woods Walker, ZS Global Moderators



Coho911 wrote:Wonder how much they'll be out of the chute....
Either :
a) Great price to promote them
or
b) Lets make some of our research money back, overprice them and possibly sink the technology.
Veritas wrote:This is cool, however:
It looks breakable. It might not be, but it is certainly complicated enough that failure should be a concern.
The feet look plastic. That seems like a bad idea in the long run.
Jaxathon wrote:Veritas wrote:This is cool, however:
It looks breakable. It might not be, but it is certainly complicated enough that failure should be a concern.
The feet look plastic. That seems like a bad idea in the long run.
The thing I would see failing first is the fan.

Zombies And SlimJims wrote:Jaxathon wrote:Veritas wrote:This is cool, however:
It looks breakable. It might not be, but it is certainly complicated enough that failure should be a concern.
The feet look plastic. That seems like a bad idea in the long run.
The thing I would see failing first is the fan.
In the demo videos the guy had the flame burning nice and hot, and I guess it's so well insulated that he was just picking up the stove with the flame going and handling it like nothing, so heat won't be an issue I don't think. And as far as storage, the fan unit itself stores right inside the stove while it's packed..It might last a while. Then again, it might break right away...I say wait until some other suckers pick one up first and review it
Jaxathon wrote:If I am correct though they used a medium to high CFM computer fan. Those are not really ment to suck in smoke or a lot of dirt which would happen if used for a bit of time. Most likely the fan will seize after a while if that is the type of fan that is inside of it. But those fans are cheap and easy to get so if it does seize you can probably just replace it with little problem.
Veritas wrote:Jaxathon wrote:If I am correct though they used a medium to high CFM computer fan. Those are not really ment to suck in smoke or a lot of dirt which would happen if used for a bit of time. Most likely the fan will seize after a while if that is the type of fan that is inside of it. But those fans are cheap and easy to get so if it does seize you can probably just replace it with little problem.
I was thinking fan also. Just the nature of the whole blower device seems prone to failure after a lot of use. Honestly, I don't know how the heat transfer device works, but anything that is heating up and cooling down a lot seems like it could be susceptible to Murphy. This may be a totally unfair judgement, and I have obviously not handled it.
I will be cautiously optimistic though, because I really like the concept of wood gas stoves, and I was planning on building one with an old computer fan at some point, which (as Jax mentioned) is essentially what this is. I will be watching this to see how much they cost. You could just get one of these: http://www.zzstove.com/sierra.html although it is not nearly as high-tech.
111t wrote:Also, if you'll excuse the observation, despite the patagonia fleece, the guy in that vid doesn't strike me as an avid outdoorsman. The trick to pour the burning embers into your cookpot seems a little on the neurotic/goofy side.
111t wrote:Ok, i will say the thermo electric wizbang is interesting. Beyond that the only thing it has over a juice can wood burner is the double walled design. I'm sure a little careful thought and a fish aireator could yield similar results (albiet battery powered.) The thing is, in a survival situation, I'd have no problem cooking on small wood fires. It's much lighter and bound to be less expensive. Also, if you'll excuse the observation, despite the patagonia fleece, the guy in that vid doesn't strike me as an avid outdoorsman. The trick to pour the burning embers into your cookpot seems a little on the neurotic/goofy side.
Sorry, to be such a downer...
YMMV
Here's a DIY that i like...
http://www.backpacking.net/makegear/fal ... index.html
modustollens wrote:I bet there is a thermoelectric generator in that. I have seen a few of these stoves which have been incorporating such power units.
I just ordered A TEG off ebay for 16.00...
http://cgi.ebay.com/THERMOELECTRIC-POWE ... 4837c458f0


Users browsing this forum: AeroRat, RonnyRonin and 25 guests