anvilbuck wrote:Sorry my pics are gone and so is the star.
Hey! I never got to look at those!
Another option I've seen someone do is to use a gear as the head of a type of flanged mace. It isn't a pointy type morning star, though, so the principle is different.
Regarding the quality of steel, I know railroad spikes are used to make knives (this isn't the first I've heard of that) so I presume they're decent steel, certainly good enough for a morning star. They don't need to "hold an edge" or anything.
Gears are usually made of tough stuff, so the gear flanged mace would have that advantage. Also, usually they've got a hole in the middle already, so all you've got to do is haft it.